

The name-only title for this collection is telling indicator of its subject’s stature. No “Master of the Turkish Clarinet” tagline necessary, Mustafa Kandirali’s name speaks for itself amongst fans and scholars of Turkish music. Traditional Crossroads gives Kandirali the royal treatment in terms of packaging too with a slipcase and 100-page hardbound book as accoutrements to a 15-track disc culling the purported best of his work from the 1970s and 80s. Where the collection falters is in the accompanying essays, which are long on superlatives and adoration, but bereft of discographical specifics. It’s an odd omission considering the number of pages the compilers had at their disposal. Frustrating as that facet of the presentation is, the music is anything but, featuring Kandirali’s keening clarinet in spectrum of settings from solo to small group accompaniment. Building on the innovations of Sukru Tunar, the acknowledged high doyen of Turkish microtonal clarinet, his is the equivalent of that “high lonesome sound” heard across cultures in everything from Roscoe Holcomb’s Kentucky hymnody to the Sufi devotionals of Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan. Expert accompaniment on oud, violin, darbuka and def bracket Kandirali’s whirling improvisations on taksim, romani and havasi song forms sometimes at vertigo-inducing tempos. Compiled mainly from LP and cassette releases, the fidelity of the recordings is uniformly excellent. Kandirali’s passion and genius are helpful reminders that conventional Western music constitutes but a drop in the bucket in the larger scheme of global musical activity.
Posted by derek on July 9, 2007 8:20 PMI need this.
Posted by: clifford at July 10, 2007 11:47 PMTraditional Crossroads is easily the most prolific American-based label specializing in Middle Eastern/Turkish music. Their catalog (and that of their umbrella label, Rounder) has so many great titles. Here are a few of my favourites:
Udi Hrant: The Early Recordings Volumes I & II [blind udist who also plays violin, some of the tracks have Sukru Tunar on clarinet (big influence on Kandirali)]
Tanburi Cemil Bey: Volumes I-V [probably the most famous early 20th cen. Turkish composer. Wax cylinder recordings from 1910 to 1914. Sound is rough & washed out in places, but the power of the music is preserved.]
Masters of Turkish Music, Vols. 1 & 2 (Rounder), Istanbul 1925, Women of Istanbul, and Armenians on 8th Avenue. [Excellent compilations of Pre-War recordings by a wide range of artists]
Posted by: Herbert Melish at July 16, 2007 6:42 AMDad, where are you? I thought the Rounder offices said you couldn't be reached, that you were in a very important meeting with the promotions department.
I wonder how this compares to the "Frankfurt Oyun Havalari" disc. I wasn't too crazy about that one for a "master." For Turkish discs, one of my favorites is the Ocora title, "Musiques Des Yayla" with some fantastic violin playing.
Posted by: Ted Melish at July 16, 2007 11:33 AM.................................................. © 2003 - 2006 bagatellen ..................................................