Dizzy Gillespie-Charlie Parker Quintet - Town Hall, New York City, June 22, 1945

townhall.jpg

Uptown 27.51

Even with nearly a century’s worth of recordings at their fingertips --a sum far beyond what any one person could reasonably consume in a lifetime-- jazz fans still pine for lost finds. The last couple years have been particularly kind in this regard with not one, but two, epochal archival discoveries: a live recording of Trane with Monk that purportedly eclipses its fidelity-impaired precursor on Blue Note in virtually every way, and this airshot from a June 22, 1945 Town Hall gig by the Dizzy Gillespie-Charlie Parker Quintet. I haven’t yet heard the former trove and therefore can’t comment on its associative claims. But Town Hall more than earns all the brouhaha surrounding its emergence and release.

The back-story reads right out of an R. Crumb or Harvey Pekar comic. Record collector receives a mysterious call relating the availability of several Charlie Parker acetates for purchase. His encyclopedic knowledge of Bird’s discography pinpoints the bounty as an unreleased concert and he quickly acquires transfers of the platters. Professionally recorded and without gaps or major blemishes, the music completely surpasses his expectations. It’s the sort of divine providence that instantly becomes the province of jazz lore. The sad news for collectors is that the concert’s second half featuring Errol Garner’s band remains unreleased thanks to the unwillingness of the pianist’s estate to greenlight its circulation. But any grousing is a case of sour grapes when the available wine is this fine.

The gig is dominated by Dizzy’s tunes and times at an economical LP length of forty or so minutes. Unfortunately it also has the boorish Symphony Sid as loquacious emcee. Al Haig occupies the piano bench with Curley Russell handling bass and Max Roach at the drum kit. The band sounds marvelous, though there is a liminal stretch where the sound engineer fiddles a bit with the balance in the opening bars of “Bebop” to bring the horns in line with the rhythm section. Don Byas’ tenor joins the frontline on this number, initially as a stopgap for the perpetually tardy Parker. It’s only a tantalizing taste and he drops out before the return to the theme.

Parker’s alto exercises the agility of a jackrabbit, bounding through the changes of “A Night in Tunisia,” but it’s Gillepsie’s muted cadenza that elicits the rousing ovation. Even Russell’s strings are cleanly audible, a circumstance not present on the various contemporary recordings from the left coast issued on labels like Spotlite and Savoy. Haig is still a bit wet behind the ears when it comes to the harmonic rigors of bop, but he collects plenty of solo room and ramps things up on a riotous rendering of “Salt Peanuts.” That tune also features some ferocious Roach and arguably Parker’s most incandescent improvisations of the night. Sid Catlett sits in on the two closing tracks and his flamboyant stick play sustains the heat on a burning version of “Hot House.” The band signs the set off with Monk’s “Fifty Second Street Theme,” rendered in a terse 2:14.

In usual Uptown fashion the packaging and documentation is exemplary with essays by Ira Gitler and Bob Sunenblick (the lucky finder) as well as ancillary photos and clippings depicting Bird, Diz and sidemen (all looking svelte in their suits with youthful kissers) ready to unwittingly turn the jazz world on its collective ear. Any fan of bebop won’t need the push to pull the trigger, but casual listeners will find this set well worth the necessary green as well. With two gold strikes and counting, the next big bonanza can’t be that far behind.

~ Derek Taylor

Posted by derek on July 26, 2005 7:46 PM
Comments

Is the Monk/Trane a commercially available release?

Posted by: Lewis Radin at July 27, 2005 6:10 AM

i've seen a sept. release date for the Monk/Coltrane on Blue Note. can't wait for that one!!!

Posted by: theo at July 27, 2005 7:03 AM

Yee-haw! This is exciting! Early bebop -- before all the rules were written -- is one of my favorite periods of American music. Case in point here: Catlett sitting in on drums. And Charlie Parker was still skinny, still unknown, still dangerous. If only someone would dig up some wax by the 1943 Earl Hines band, with Bird and Dizzy and Sassy in it...

Posted by: djll at July 27, 2005 8:42 PM

Is that the Live At The Five Spot (late summer 57, with Ahmed Abdul-Malik and Roy Haynes)? Or another one?
http://www.allmusic.com/cg/amg.dll?p=amg&sql=10:dikcikkhbb69

Posted by: Dan Warburton at July 27, 2005 9:57 PM

Dan, if you're refering to the Monk/Coltrane i was under the impression that it was a benifit at Carnegie Hall (still '57 of course)...although i can't recall where i read this??? it's rumored to have much better sound than the 5 spot gig.

Posted by: theo at July 28, 2005 4:41 AM

Dan,

from an article Ben Ratliff posted in the New York Times:

"The tapes come from a concert at Carnegie Hall on Nov. 29, 1957, a benefit for a community center. The concert was recorded by the Voice of America, the international broadcasting service, and the tapes also include sets by the Dizzy Gillespie Orchestra, Ray Charles with a backing sextet, the Zoot Sims Quartet with Chet Baker, and the Sonny Rollins Trio. (Newspaper accounts of the concert indicate that Billie Holiday appeared as well, though she is not on the Voice of America tapes.)

But it is Monk with Coltrane that constitutes the real find. That band existed for only six months in 1957, mostly through long and celebrated runs at the East Village club the Five Spot. During this period, Coltrane fully collected himself as an improviser, challenged by Monk and the discipline of his unusual harmonic sense. Thus began the 10-year sprint during which he changed jazz completely, before his death in 1967. The Monk quartet with Coltrane did record three numbers in a studio in 1957, but remarkably little material, and only with fairly low audience-tape fidelity, is known to exist from the Five Spot engagement.

The eight and a half Monk performances found at the Library of Congress, by contrast, are professionally recorded, strong and clear; you can hear the full dimensions of Shadow Wilson's drum kit and Ahmed Abdul-Malik's bass. It is certainly good enough for commercial release, though none has yet been negotiated."

Posted by: john b at July 28, 2005 5:48 AM

and, getting back to the original topic, Derek's review is spot on. The Uptown disc is essential. Fantastic sound, wonderful playing by all and liner notes / photos that put most labels efforts to shame.

Posted by: john b at July 28, 2005 5:53 AM

Hello,what more can be said but that THEY did it....It had to be done.....Bird and Dizzy.....they are the fathers of a movement that is still in motion and I do mean in MOTION....In my opinion NO one has surpassed those two men....You have to realize that they are STILL being imitated.....stay young....Hollywood Joe

Posted by: Hollywood Joe at April 9, 2007 10:23 PM


Post a comment










Remember personal info?




Please enter the letter "e" in the field below:

NOTE: there will be some lag after you hit the "submit" button, but not much. That lag is our badass spam deterrent software at work. It is not necessary to use the submit button more than once. Thank you.



.................................................. © 2003 - 2006 bagatellen ..................................................