
Encounters with the electric guitar often conjure up my favorite comic book quotation. Aged Uncle Ben regaling post-spider bite Peter Parker with the adage: “with great power comes great responsibility.” Possibly Stan Lee’s most prescient pearl of wisdom. In this day and age of effects boxes, flanging pedals and Midi trickery any Average Joe can make his axe sound like an orchestra of instruments both known and arcane. The temptation to allow accoutrements to overshadow artistry is sometimes impossible for a plectrist to resist.
The first time I spun Oleo in its original cd incarnation, I arrived at the immediate (& it turns out presumptuous) conclusion that Raymond Boni had broken this cardinal rule. His general irreverence and flamboyant use of dive-bombing Doppler loops and flameout arpeggiations on the opening reading of Rollins’ sacred title track felt blasphemous to my orthodoxy-shackled ears. I barely finished the first cut before shelving the disc for the better part of a summer. The new Hatology edition of the album pokes copious holes in my initial Swiss cheese opinion. Far from a fret-foisting wanker, Boni is the blasting cap to the dynamite that is this group.
Andre Jaume on clarinet, bass clarinet and alto saxophone joins McPhee’s pocket cornet and tenor saxophone in the front line. Francois Mechali on beautifully miked double bass completes the ensemble on the first seven compositions, and compositions they are. Pieces like spine-tinglingly mellifluous “Pablo” and “Astral Spirits” encapsulate McPhee’s ecumenical marriage of jazz and European chamber music forms. His own liners describe the concept- in language I can’t help likening to Ornette’s explanations of harmelodics- of coming at musical structures from lateral vantages. Not obliterating axioms, but finding the crevices to inculcate new ideas within them. It’s in gorgeous evidence on the two versions of “Oleo” where Newk’s breakneck bebop theme still holds sway, but as springboard for expectation-bucking improvisations from all four men. It’s a coup McPhee and Mechali’s repeat on the brief but lushly realized study of Benny Golson’s “I Remember Clifford.”
Despite the theoretical basis behind the music’s construction there’s very little that feels academic or sterile about the end product. McPhee’s fabled emotive honesty is blooms with full force. Mechali’s arco solo on “Pablo” cross-hatched with flamenco filagrees from Boni’s hummingbird pick keeps any notions of egghead artifice at arms length. The leader’s Spanish tinged-tenor and Jaume’s bass clarinet drones continue to combat conceit. There’s even room for Milesian funk forwarded on the rubberball bass pops from Mechali that pepper “Future Retrospective.”
Wrapping it up, I was wrong and the music is right. This remains one of McPhee’s most eclectically adventurous outings and it sounds better than ever with a new Peter Pfister polish. Boni may never have heard of Uncle Ben, but he clearly learned the lesson originally imparted to young Parker long ago.
~ Derek Taylor
I happened to play this (the original CD) the other day and still think it holds up as one of Joe's best group efforts.
Posted by: Brian at September 1, 2004 5:35 AMDid you ever review it anywhere?
Posted by: derek at September 1, 2004 8:06 AMStan Lee coined that phrase?
Posted by: mke at September 2, 2004 4:54 AMDerek, turns out I did indeed write it up for AMG, at: http://www.allmusic.com/cg/amg.dll?p=amg&uid=SUB030409020814&sql=10:t91uak5kgm3v~T1
Posted by: Brian at September 2, 2004 5:16 AM(If one of youse guys could linkify the above, it'd be appreciated...)
Posted by: Brian at September 2, 2004 5:17 AMMy powers of linkification leave much to be desired, but I’m sure someone can plug one in (til then ye ol' cut & paste works too). Great write-up, though I noticed the typo “Andrew” Jaume :)
Mke, can’t confirm if Mr. Excelsior actually coined it, but I do believe he had a chief role in disseminating it to hordes of prepubescent comic fiends like me.
Hate to wonk into this thread, but did Pfister remaster ("polish") the Hatology "Oleo"? This has long been my fave of McPhee's catalogue, and the original CD issue sounds pretty damn good, esp. on "Pablo". Normally, when Pfister remasters a Hatology issue, the liner notes seem to reflect that fact (e.g., recent Steve Lacy & Giuffre reissues). Of course, that practice might be applied inconsistently ....
Posted by: strich at September 4, 2004 7:25 PMThanks stritch, my bad. Scrutinizing the orange script on the cardboard sleeve it doesn’t appear Mr. Pfister did any further tweaking to the source tapes for the new reissue. Either way the fidelity is fabulous.
Posted by: derek at September 7, 2004 6:46 AMNice review, Derek (as usual).
But I don't understand what you and Strich are spoken about.
Of course, like all hatOLOGY, "Oleo" had been upgrated to 24 bits has it's mention on the back of the cardboard sleeve.
It's always written at the end of the listing of the song in that order: Total Time DDD 24 bit.
Has I have, now, the two versions, I've done a quick A/B comparaison and it has been upgraded alright(Mr Pfister is the living master of the remastering. I'd like him doing an "Peter Pfister edition" of the classic Blue Note. Could bring them back to life, maybe).
The only hatOLOGY who has been republish as he was when it was first release, is the Lacy/Waldron "Live At the Dreher" because he was already, the alone of this kind in the 6000 series I believe, mastered in 24 bit.
BTW, Derek, André Jaume first name is written with an accent on the é, something than most english writting critics never care much about.
.................................................. © 2003 - 2006 bagatellen ..................................................