
Voice Crack/Gunter Muller
Buda_rom
For 4 Ears
1344
Gunter Muller
Eight Landscapes
For 4 Ears
1445
Arguably the Most Valuable Collaborator on the electro-acoustic improv scene, Gunter Muller gives a representative account of himself on these two discs, even if they fall a good distance short of his finest work.
“buda_rom” was created in partnership with Voice Crack, the recently defunct Swiss electronics duo. It’s culled from two performances in Budapest and Rome in late 2000, the Roman shows re-mixed in shortish fragments and interwoven between longer extracts from the Budapest shows. Both Muller and Voice Crack (Andy Guhl and Norbert Moslang) share a tendency toward the rhythmic that’s often absent in this rarefied world, using looped sound sources to help establish a complicated drone. This provides the new listener a relatively easy way in even though more experienced listeners may get a nagging sense of the loops being used as something of a crutch (although, admittedly, they are usually quite seductive). Voice Crack’s sounds are generally of a rougher, gnarlier nature, a crunchy approach that lends itself to the build-up of thick, complex walls of noise. Muller is smoother, silkier, sliding his contributions between the interstices, making his presence known and important almost before you realize he’s there. The longer tracks inevitably work the best here, allowing the listener to bathe for a while, soaking in the sounds. If it’s not very different from other offerings from these musicians and not quite up to the standards set on releases like poire_z’ “+” on Erstwhile (which includes the same three musicians), it’s an enjoyable enough disc and well worth hearing.
“Eight Landscapes” marks the first time Muller has recorded as a solo artist and, while it is an attractive offering, shows why he might be better served as a collaborator with others. With nothing to act as a foil for his gentler tendencies, the pieces occasionally drift into fairly ambient territory, sometimes reminiscent of early Eno (though still with more grit but perhaps, on the other hand, lacking Eno’s wit). A rough edge appears now and then as on the second track where an unsettling, high-pitched buzz like that of a faraway saw slicing through metal lends an appealing harshness to the otherwise billowy background. While the music here is not, in a sense, very different from that which Muller creates in other contexts, there may be a subtle element missing, one that elevates it from perfectly fine work to something more. As with the prior disc, “Eight Landscapes” is by no means a bad recording; it’s attractive and even a little bit luxuriant. Somehow, I want to hear just a little more bite, something a bit more surprising and unexpected. Muller may have it in him to come up with this on his own one of these days, but for the time being, I hear it surface more often when he’s playing off the contributions of others. As a partner to musicians like Rowe, Otomo or Nakamura, he’s unbeatable.
yeah, I agree with most of that. you don't mention that you were there when Gunter decided/was talked into doing the solo disc, on the ride up to Boston in 2002. the solo disc is interesting to me because, as you say, he subsumes his musical personality so much on collaborative projects, even on duo discs (very difficult, not to mention rare), and he obviously can't do that in this context.
also, does Eno really have wit in his ambient works? the lyrics on the early records, sure, but on the ambient records? I don't know them very well, so I'm half-questioning, half-asking.
Posted by: Jon Abbey at October 26, 2003 9:09 AMre: Eno's wit--It's likely a subjective appraisal, but I hear a little bit of sly humor in things like his variations on Pachelbel (from 'Discreet Music') and in some of the tracks from 'On Land'.
Posted by: brian at October 28, 2003 7:22 AMEno's a scream, whaddyatalkingabout? All those wacky oscillator solos with Roxy (a propos: a lice but typically Penmanian review of Roxy on his blogspot (apawboy.blogspot.com if I remember right)), all the tongue-in-cheek lyrics on the 70s solo albums, not to mention the Portsmouth Sinfonia! About time we had someone with a sense of humour in improv.. I guess Taku Sugimoto has one, if Clive Bell's new Wire piece is anything to go off!
Re the best ofs, just a gratuitous plug for the November 2003 issue of Paris Transatlantic online as of tomorrow, which will feature an interview with Rhodri Davies (www.paristransatlantic.com as ever)
Lice? Jesus, I need typing lessons. NICE.
ps the new Voicecrack with Carlos Zingaro on Sirr is lice too
Posted by: dan warburton at October 31, 2003 10:58 AMDan, Dan, Dan. I was talking about alleged humor in Eno's ambient works, not his entire ouevre. I also mentioned the lyrics on the solo records...
Martin Tetreault was pretty funny at points in his solo set at Tonic last night, FWIW...
Posted by: Jon Abbey at October 31, 2003 11:52 AMooh, ooh, I don't agree about the Muller/Voice Crack. The loops put it closer in line with, say, Wolf Eyes, than with poire_z; to my ears, it sounds like it's working more in the vein of 80's industrial, Throbbing Gristle, SPK, MB (the 2nd side of "Mecypto Bacterium" bears something of a family rememblance). Chris Wolf turned me onto this one, we're both interested in that area/era of music. I actually think it's a pretty special piece of work.
Oh, but Gunter Muller also gets my vote as MVP. The fanny pack just distances him even farther from the pack. Oh man, what a guy.
Posted by: Nirav Soni at November 3, 2003 8:06 PM.................................................. © 2003 - 2006 bagatellen ..................................................