

Like most people my age and older, I still remember seeing Star Wars when it came out theatrically, in an ancient movie house in Vancouver when I was six, sharing shouts of approval with the enthusiastic Canadian audience. Several years later, I went to with a friend and his parents to a screening of Lucas’ first commercial release at Fairhaven College, the counter-culture counterpart to the state university in my hometown. I don’t recall much from that original exposure to the film other than the final 15-minute action sequence that synched well with my prepubescent sensibilities and still stands as a memorable milepost in 70s cinema. The rest was a blur of unintelligible imagery and sound. Since then, the title has repeatedly fallen through the fissures in my film consumption. I have read several commentaries about it over the years, but for some inexplicable reason have never revisited it. A Director’s cut DVD copy checked out from the library recently changed that.
Much has been written about the film’s sci-fi plot and visuals, particularly the context of the director’s subsequent success with the highest grossing franchise in film history. The nameless numbered protagonist, here played by a young Robert Duvall, and his gradual awakening from a pharmaceutical-derived stupor to the horrors of his homogenized and dehumanized world has now almost become clichéd in the genre of science fiction. One of the most effective scenes illustrating this reality involves two unseen techicians monitoring Duvall’s imprisoned character via video screen. One is training in the recently transferred other and their ensuing dial twiddling and flip-switching leads to severe psycho-physiological trauma for the otherwise clueless Duvall, undercut with more banal banter and techno babble. It’s a sequence both disturbing and darkly humorous and one that runs directly at odds with a clip from a vintage Buck Rogers serial that prefaces the film and imagines the future as an arcadia teeming hi-tech wonders. The script is actually riddled with this sort of pseudo-technological and religious doubletalk, presumably to further the impression of a society so bureaucratized and faceless that the human element is all but lost. But its presence is so abundant that it soon starts to feel overwrought.
Lucas has long been derided for his handicaps concerning character development. Those impediments are not much of an issue in this setting, where even a modicum of original thought and expression separates the individual from the sheep. Duvall does a decent job depicting THX-1138’s transformation from chattel to dissident, mapping an emotional ping-pong pattern from confusion, to fear, to anger, to tenderness and back. Other character actors in the oddly eclectic cast include Donald Pleasance, as a creepy voyeur desperate for companionship who, despite his protestations and rationalizations to the contrary, finds himself just as institutionalized as his compatriots, Sid Haig, who would go on to become an icon of 70s and 80s schlock cinema, and Johnny Weissmuller, Jr., son of MGM’s Tarzan, as one of the proto-Stormtrooper robot sentries.
Despite the dated nature of some technology, Lucas’ dystopian world holds up pretty well. Most of the populace is parceled into highly dangerous drone-like manufacturing work where triple-digit on-the-job fatalities are factored into monthly production quotas. Downtime consists of the numbing trifecta of mandatory consumerism, drug intake and holographic entertainment either erotic, violent or monotonous in content. A menu of pills and interactive medicine cabinets are part of the daily routine. Everyone is assigned a white jump suit and maintains a shaved cranium to discourage individualist impulses. All are familiar futurist tropes, given an early-70s spin by Lucas and co-screen writer Walter Murch, who also shows off his fledgling genius for sound editing and design with complex montages and splices throughout the film. Lalo Schiffrin’s largely electronic score completes the aural side of the equation, mixing interludes of poignancy with passages of overlying ennui. It’s the sort of thing he would go on to perfect in later films like The Conversation and Apocalypse Now.
As with his Star Wars trilogy, Lucas went back to the original film cut and augmented various sections with Industrial Light & Magic upgrades for the re-release. Some, like various large-scale city shots and a concluding sequence obviously employing new millennial CGI, are easy to spot. Others are less so. None really adds that much to the picture and the most striking imagery still lies in the scenes describing Duvall’s imprisonment in the antiseptic white cell seemingly without walls. It’s a concentration camp in the literal sense of the phrase, where recusants are sent to reflect at length on their transgressions. The ease of Duvall’s eventual initial escape also points to the pervasiveness of the conformist worldview. The surveillance guards are so anesthetized by the status quo that they simply allow him to walk out. When realization of his departure does register, a special budget is assembled to finance his recapture and a running tally records its depletion. In the end, his freedom hinges solely on the cost-effectiveness of venture. It’s a set of circumstances with sharp metaphorical corollaries to the economic shift from studio to corporate ownership occurring in the American cinema of the era and the succession artistically stultifying side effects that came with the switch.
Posted by derek on January 20, 2007 3:57 PMTest.
Posted by: derek at January 21, 2007 11:51 AMWow, good review. Thanks. I'm going to rewatch Star Wars now, and hopefully the eewok movies too. I forget that things were radically different from when the franchise first came out. I hope everyone gets to see the trilogy at least twice in their lifetimes :)
Posted by: Mark at January 22, 2007 6:19 AMThanks, Mark. One of the things I still find strange about this flim is its "R" rating for "nudity and sexuality". There is a brief scene involving an attempted sexual assault, but the MPAA standards policing nudity while routinely green lighting violence still cause me to scratch my head.
As far as Star Wars: the original trilogy has lost a lot of its luster for me, though Empire Strikes Back still holds up pretty well as a sci-fi/action flick. The prequel trilogy isn't something I ever plan to revisit.
Posted by: derek at January 22, 2007 8:10 AMSad to hear Lucas has "improved" the visuals with CGI on this one too. I recently revisited the Star Wars films in the company of my daughter, & while in general I found them a lot, uh, lousier than I'd remembered, the really disconcerting thing was the clumsy insertion of CGI into the original film (the seams really show).
BTW I think you double-posted both this article & the Kanal piece.
Posted by: nd at January 22, 2007 8:49 AMBTW I think you double-posted both this article & the Kanal piece.
That was intentional.
I haven't seen the revamped Star Wars films, but can imagine that new ILM-engineered segments stick out like sore thumbs. There's an interesting bit of commentary included with the DVD where Lucas posits one day returning to his "avant garde" roots. Personally, I think he's to the point where that probably isn't possible (if it ever was). He's a far better technological innovator than a filmmaker.
Posted by: derek at January 22, 2007 9:03 AMI quite enjoy this film and in general this was a good review. The CG additions in this are pretty minor, nothing like the massive amount of effort that went into the Special Editions. In the main they are adding some traffic to the car chase scene and some digital monkeys in the background of one scene. There is some website that goes over all of the changes if you are interested. I really find Lucas' filmmaking at this point very interesting, there is some very novel and effective camera work and unique shots. If you watch Star Wars (A New Hope I guess) you can see some of this has carried over. The sound design as well, especially on the Death Star, evokes THX at times with its collection of technological sounds and detached voices. After Star Wars Lucas seemed to have mostly lost these more experimental techniques, but I'll be curious to see what he does in these supposed small films he claims he wants to focus on now.
Speaking just a bit on THX I really thinks this rates right up there as one of the best of dystopian films. Its examination of depersonalization, of the replacement of humanity with technology and faceless totalitarianism still resonates. Lucas and Murch very wisely didn't go into any back story of how humanity ended up in these compounds (probably an allusion to nuclear war back in the day, but it could just as easily be dramatic climate change or a biological disaster). As mentioned above the sound design in this film is absolutely brilliant. I'd love an isolated score on the DVD which alas it doesn't have. It does have several good features on the audio work and Murch is on the commentary track. There is also a pair of excellent documentaries about the early Lucas work and American Zoetrope. This film had a tough birthing process and that really led to making Lucas into what he became. The other feature on the DVD that I had been wanting to see for ages was the original student film version that so impressed Coppola that he was able to do a feature length version of it. Finally there is a non "directors cut" version of this on DVD for those who wish to avoid the additions, though it includes none of these fascinating extras.
Posted by: Robert at January 22, 2007 11:33 AMThat must be the Special Edition of the DVD. The version I screened was the budget one, which only contains a Lucas/Murch commentary track and original theatrical trailer as extras. Those documentaries do sound interesting and it’d be great to see the original film short. I found the cgi to be a bit more than “minor” with obvious inserts at various points throughout the film, mostly to more effectively convey the immensity of the underground complex.
The fleeting appearance of wildlife in the final shot (one that draws a strong parallel to finale of Planet of the Apes subtly and succinctly illustrates the lie under which Duvall's character has been living.
Posted by: derek at January 22, 2007 2:46 PM@ Robert.
Regarding the isolated sound score. My dvd version of THX has this. Perhaps you should shop around for the special edition. It's worth it.
Posted by: Matt at January 22, 2007 5:23 PMI do have the Special Edition, I must have just missed that. Good news anyway!
This is the page I alluded to with the various changes:
THX-1138 Changes
In which you can see that the bulk was cleaning up and some enhancements. The scenes I mentioned above were the most dramatic changes in my mind and I mentioned the monkeys mainly as they were the most obviously CGI changes to me.
Posted by: Robert at January 23, 2007 11:44 AMWhat is it with Bags eating posted links? Anyway that page is:
One last try:
If this doesn't work:
http://tinyurl.com/yqbtuf
Robert, you forgot URL quotes in the first link and tags in the second. Third times a charm. :)
Posted by: derek at January 23, 2007 3:22 PM.................................................. © 2003 - 2006 bagatellen ..................................................