Thanks to the efforts of regular Bagatellen readers "mcgr" and Emory Davis, the comments (except those of the author himself) to Chris Kelsey's articles New-Ness And Jazz-Ness (February 21, 2005) and A Coda (Whereupon A Jazz Guy Learns A New Acronym And Makes Some New Enemies) (March 4, 2005) have been restored to the site.
New-Ness And Jazz-Ness: Comments
A Coda (Whereupon A Jazz Guy Learns A New Acronym And Makes Some New Enemies): Comments
Posted by admin on March 19, 2005 1:52 PMThis is odd. Why do "mcgr" and Emory Davis want this rehashed? I thought this exchange nauseated everyone.
Posted by: Jared/sonic1 at March 21, 2005 6:21 PMand what admin. person posted this?
Posted by: Jared/sonic1 at March 21, 2005 7:12 PMJared,
As I understand it, this isn't a rehashing. It's a placeholder for the comment sections that got iced with the original excising of Chris' essays. Some readers voiced concern that "the baby was thrown out with the bath water", so to speak, so those sections are preserved here in perpetuity (or until Bags folds) as an archive.
And to answer your second question... the illustrious & indefatigable Emory Davis was the admin person responsible for the posting.
Posted by: derek at March 21, 2005 8:09 PMAnd no, Jared, the exchange did not nauseate everyone.
Posted by: Vincent Kargatis at March 22, 2005 10:49 AMI see Mr Kelsey is back in business on OFN, with a particularly negative review of Bertrand Gauguet's solo sax album ETWA (on Creative Sources). http://www.onefinalnote.com/reviews/g/gauguet-bertrand/etwa.asp
Makes for an interesting comparison with Jason Bivins' take on the same album in the latest Signal To Noise.. any comments, anyone?
any comments, anyone?
Not really Dan, no.
Its a thinly veiled attempt to reignite pointless, boring arguments that for everyone's sake is probably better off left ignored.
Posted by: Richard Pinnell at June 23, 2005 4:11 PM.................................................. © 2003 - 2006 bagatellen ..................................................